Dear Clients & Friends,
In last quarter’s letter, we wrote about the return of animal spirits to the markets, as exuberant investor behavior drove stocks to all-time highs with the S&P 500 posting consecutive 20%+ return years. However, sentiment can change quickly, and it did so during the first quarter of 2025. We’ll explore why stocks declined and, more importantly, why stock declines are expected and normal, regardless of the circumstances. As P&A celebrates our 30th anniversary this year, we’ll revisit our investment philosophy that has guided our firm since inception.
If you follow the markets, you might have heard the term “priced in” mentioned by an analyst or financial pundit. For example, “Markets have largely priced in two interest rate cuts for 2025.” Priced in simply means the market expects or has accounted for a specific thing happening or not happening. Volatility occurs when markets are caught off guard and an event is not priced in.
When we talk about markets, we mean the collection of buyers and sellers, investors with different motivations, timelines, risk profiles, political leanings, experience levels, etc. Some participants are individuals, and some are institutions. Some are short-term traders, while others are long-term investors. When new information becomes available–the latest inflation reading or a company’s earnings report–market participants react in real-time, depending on their expectations for the news. Due to market participants’ collective knowledge, wisdom, and experience, the result is the most accurate estimate of our future, at least in business and economics. Yes, markets do get things wrong occasionally, but often, they are directionally right.
Why the stock market declined
The S&P 500 hit an all-time high on February 19th, and by March 13th, it had declined by 10%, the definition of a correction. Stocks trimmed their losses to finish the quarter down 4.6% year-to-date. The Nasdaq fell by 10.4%, while the Dow Industrials declined 1.3%. We believe three main factors contributed to the decline.
First, the companies that powered the market higher during four of the last five years–the Magnificent Seven–finally cooled off. When these companies reported earnings in February, they failed to impress investors enough. Additionally, a Chinese artificial intelligence company developed an AI model with comparable performance to the leading U.S. models, using less advanced chips, and at a reported lower cost, which weighed on these stocks. As the quarter continued, tech stocks came under further pressure on economic growth, inflation, trade, and recession concerns. By the end of March, the Magnificent Seven stocks were down 15% from their recent highs.
Second, optimism over a “pro-growth, less regulation, and lower taxes” administration and a soft landing on final approach turned into pessimism about slowing growth, persistent inflation, and lower employment. Confusion around tariffs and trade policy rattled markets in March. Uncertainty around the impact of government layoffs was also a factor. Recession and stagflation re-entered the lexicon.
Third, U.S government debt and deficit levels continue to head in the wrong direction. The first five months of the U.S. government’s fiscal year (Oct ‘24 – Feb ‘25) resulted in a deficit of $1.15 trillion, on pace for an annual deficit of $2.75 trillion. Additionally, $28 trillion of our country’s $37 trillion in outstanding government debt needs to be refinanced over the next four years. Interest on the debt is on track to hit $1.2 trillion, more than we spend on defense. These aren’t sustainable numbers.
New Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent commented that stock market corrections were healthy. He also said, “The market and the economy have become hooked, become addicted, to excessive government spending, and there’s going to be a detox period.” While both statements may be factual, markets didn’t like hearing this from the Secretary of the Treasury.
Stock market declines happen every year
Nineteen years ago, my wife and I were on a flight returning from our honeymoon when out of nowhere we hit a pocket of air and our plane dropped suddenly and dramatically. This experience rattled many passengers; there were audible gasps, several screams, and some spilled drinks. After a brief second or two, we escaped the air pocket and the plane stabilized. From then on, the flight was uneventful.
Investing in the stock market is like this experience, with one big exception: it’s rarely uneventful. Turbulence is the rule, not the exception. Markets hit a lot of air pockets. The “fasten seat belt” sign should always be illuminated for investors. As our own Dan Frost reminded us recently, stocks take the stairs up and the elevator down. (Be sure to read his monthly market recaps on our blog.)
Stock market corrections are critical in laying the groundwork for future growth by burning off excesses. Resilient businesses and long-term investors often emerge stronger from market and economic downturns and stand ready to capitalize on the opportunities that follow. Over the last 25 years, the U.S. stock market and economy have experienced four bear markets, five corrections, and three recessions. But over the previous 15 years (2010-2024), the U.S. economy has spent only two months in an official recession…two months out of 180.
Each quarter, we receive chartbooks from various Wall Street firms. Charles Schwab includes a graph showing annual stock market returns and the largest intra-year declines. I asked Jaxson Simmerman from our research team to convert the data to a table, which appears below.
The highlighted cells represent years when the stock market declined by at least 10% during the year but finished with a positive return. This has occurred 15 times over the last 45 years, one-third of the time. The smallest intra-year decline was 3%, while the average was a 14% decline. The median intra-year decrease was 10%. In other words, stock market declines are normal and expected; they happen every year. Most declines are short-lived. Of the last 15 stock market corrections, 13 saw stocks higher one year later, by an average of 15%, according to SandyLeeds.com.

History has shown time and time again that when the stock market goes down, it’s a buying opportunity. Every single time throughout the stock market’s long history, stocks eventually recovered and have gone on to new highs. Is it possible this time is different? Yes, it’s possible. Is it probable? Not according to history.
I also asked Jaxson to produce the following table, which shows the percentage of the time the stock market was positive or negative over various rolling periods (data from 1896 to 2024).

Those are stunning odds in favor of investors: stocks are up 84% of the time over five years and 90% over 10 years. Even over one-month periods, stocks gain in value 61% of the time. These two charts help inform our investment philosophy, to which we now turn.
P&A’s investment philosophy revisited
It’s been some time since we shared our investment philosophy in this letter. We believe it’s an appropriate time to do so. I asked our Chief Investment Officer, Shane Riley, to describe our beliefs and approach succinctly. Here’s his response: “Our approach to investing balances a persistent focus on process with a commitment to embracing change, which allows us to pursue the best opportunities while managing risk for long-term success.”
You’ll notice in Shane’s answer that while we focus on process, we aren’t dogmatic or resistant to change. One of our firm’s founding principles is that when the facts change, we change our minds. Shane also mentions the balance between reaching for return and being cognizant of risk. His statements might seem contradictory, but they acknowledge the constant conflict in the markets between buyers and sellers, fear and greed, risk and return. Paired concepts like these can’t exist without each other, like light and dark. They are dynamic, and there is constant tension between the two. The bull and the bear in P&A’s logo represent this yin and yang of the markets.
Going deeper, long-term ownership of high-quality, durable businesses is an enduring strategy. Our Research Committee meets regularly to review current holdings, factors and economic conditions impacting these companies, and propose new client portfolio ideas. Their rigorous analysis and outside research resources at our disposal inform our decisions. But as Shane says, “investing is both an art and a science. Some things are measurable, and others require intuition.” He adds that we want to make “fewer, but better decisions” and that “80% of our results are driven by 20% of our ideas.”
We aren’t market timers. Jumping in and out of the markets based on someone’s prediction of what might happen isn’t a sustainable approach. Predictions are often wrong; so, we need to avoid chasing them. Instead, we want to focus on what we can control.
The activity you see in your portfolio consists of pulling weeds and planting flowers. Sticking to this process over time, through good markets and bad, has been the right approach. We don’t see that changing. We’ve built your investment portfolio to withstand the ups and downs, to be resilient. We aim to avoid costly mistakes and stay disciplined, which we know are the keys to long-term investing success.
Actions to consider
The completely normal reaction to market volatility is the desire to do something. Markets like these provide opportunities. Here are three actions to consider if your financial situation applies:
- Have P&A update your financial plan. Market downturns occur in the short term, while a financial plan focuses on the long term. Updating and reviewing your financial plan can give you confidence and reassurance. If any changes are necessary, our planning process will help to uncover them. Finding a long-term investment mix that works for you is key to these efforts.
- Roth conversions – Down markets provide a good opportunity to consider converting pre-tax IRA monies into a Roth IRA. Any conversions are taxable as ordinary income, so they work best for people expecting a lower income year or with room in their current marginal tax bracket. Consult your accountant and/or P&A to discuss if this interests you.
- Excess cash in the bank – If you have more than you need for an emergency fund or known upcoming expenses, down markets provide a good opportunity to buy stocks on sale. Historically, this buy-the-dip strategy has paid off eventually.
The World According to P&A
This year marks the 30th anniversary of P&A’s founding. To celebrate, we are planning a party this summer! Invitations should be in the mail sometime in May. Thank you to all who’ve been on this ride with us. You are why we come to work every day, and because you trusted in us, we’ve grown exponentially. Today, we manage over $3 billion in client assets for 850+ households nationwide.
Our team continues to grow! We’re excited to announce the hiring of Julie Sellers. She comes to P&A with a strong background in financial services, having been in the industry for 25 years. She will be a Service Advisor, joining Elizabeth, Kristin, Soren, and A.J. As you know, our Service Advisors make things happen and allow the rest of us to look good. They are integral to how our client service structure operates. Read more about Julie in her P&A spotlight, and read Blake’s Behind the Scenes post on Service Advisors from May 2024.
Lastly, thank you to all our clients who completed our survey. The feedback is greatly valued. We’re in the process of distilling the insights into action items, so more to come on this soon.
On behalf of the entire P&A team, thank you for reading.
Jon Sevenker, CFP®
Senior Advisor/Principal
The statements in this quarterly letter do not constitute an offer to sell, a solicitation of an offer to buy, or a recommendation of any security or any other product or service by Pittenger & Anderson or any other third party regardless of whether this letter references such security, product, or service. To learn more about our firm and investment approach, check out our Form ADV.
To download a PDF version of our quarterly letter, click here.